One tester said: “I loved it straight out of the jar on breakfast burritos, fish tacos, and even on my scrambled eggs. So yummy!”
Best Ketchup
Best Ketchup: Smash Kitchen Hot Honey Ketchup
Why we love it: Name something spicier than a hot honey ketchup created by Glenn Powell, we dare you. While it only has a slight, lingering kick, this sweet x spicy x smoky collab is sure to bring fire to your burger, fries, eggs, or really any bite you’d put OG ketchup on.
One tester said: “A good ketchup is one you often take for granted. I was super curious to try Glenn Powell’s, which was supposed to be fresh and delicious AND super affordable—and it definitely impressed me. The hot honey adds a nice, subtle kick to a pretty boring/standard condiment, and I personally didn’t find it overly sweet.”
Best Mayo
Best Mayo: Ayoh! Foods Sando Sauces
Why we love it: Let’s face it, mayo isn’t always exciting. Enter these Sando Sauces. They’re a true game changer. With flavors like hot giardinayo, tangy dijon-ayo, and briny dill pickle, Ayoh (founded by influencer/chef Molly Baz) takes the condiment to an entirely new planet. Each sauce is light, vibrant, and jam-packed with flavor to accompany any fare your heart desires.
One tester said: “I literally don’t think I can go back to regular mayonnaise (sorry, not sorry). The packaging is adorable, the bottles are easy to squeeze, and the sauce inside makes everything better! I feel like they could even convert the mayo hater crew—they’re that good.”
Best Aioli
Best Aioli: Chosen Foods Dip & Drizzle Sauces Made with 100% Pure Avocado Oil
Why we love it: With each flavor packing its own signature punch, you’ll want to do more than just dip and drizzle this Chosen Foods trifecta. The burger sauce elevates anything (not just burgers!) with a mustardy tang, the everything bagel sauce adds oomph to whatever it touches, and the chicken sauce almost perfectly dupes Chick-fil-a’s signature zing.
One tester said: “I’m a big sauce gal, and these did not disappoint. Enough said.”
Best Spreads
Best Almond Butter: Justin’s Honey Almond Butter
Why we love it: With the slightest hint of sweetness, Justin’s honey almond butter is the deluxe companion your toast has lived far too long without. It’s balanced in both flavor and texture—thick, spreadable, and smooth, with just enough bite. What more could you ask for?
One tester said: “I spread this almond butter on toast and bagels and added a dollop of it to both oatmeal and yogurt. It was delicious in every form.”
Best Smooth Peanut Butter: Barney Butter Smooth Peanut Butter
Why we love it: For a silky, decadent peanut butter, look no further than Barney Butter. Spread on a sandwich (may we recommend a fluffernutter?) or eat it plain, right out of the jar. If luxury was a taste, the contents of this jar would be it.
One tester said: “I loved the consistency—perfectly smooth!”
Best Creamy Peanut Butter: Good Good Creamy Peanut Butter
Why we love it: Excellent peanut butter can feel like a time machine. Good Good is soul-nourishing, hearty, and incognito healthy, tasting just like your favorite childhood jar—minus that oily film at the top. Win, win.
